Oklahoma Hunting Forum banner

Including Lost Deer in Your Bag Limit

152 Views 10 Replies 7 Participants Last post by  Archer22
I'm doing some research, looking at surrounding states for setting up a deer camp next year. My buddy conceded he's a bit too long in the tooth to attempt spike camping for elk in the mountains, so we are conjuring up an old fashioned deer hunt somewhere out of state, somewhere new.

I have been reading and something in the Missouri regs caught my attention: "Retrieval of game. If you kill or injure a deer, you must make a reasonable effort to retrieve and include the animal in your season limit."

The way I interpret this is if you shoot and injure a deer, whether you recover it or not, you have to punch your tag. Now I witnessed this at javelina camp in TX last year, one of the guys failed to locate a wounded javie so he considered his tag punched and he was done javie hunting. I've known other hunters do this for moral reasons. How do you all feel about that being a law?

I'm interested in hearing your feedback: What do you do when you wound one, are you done or do you keep hunting? Anyone aware of any other states with that kinda reg?

On topic, one season I nicknamed my buddy "the Maimer" because he shot and wounded so many deer: shot one in the ass, skinned one's belly, shot one in the side of the head. Hell, he even shot one I nicknamed "Achilles" because he shot him in the ankle and the arrow was still attached when he walked off. lol Funny, but not funny.

Just curious what you all think about counting wounded and lost animals towards your season limit.
  • Like
Reactions: 2
1 - 11 of 11 Posts
It's not uncommon for guys with tracking dogs who trail a wounded deer and not find it and the deer appears again on cam sometimes several days or even weeks later. There's no shortage of deer imo. That's why OK requires a skull tag for found skulls imo also.
  • Like
Reactions: 2
I haven’t lost a deer in 19 years, but I wounded one three years ago that showed back up on camera alive. I quit hunting for the year after I wounded that one. I actually killed him the next season, and he was a lot bigger. I’m not opposed to having to “tag” a lost deer, but in my opinion, it’s an unenforceable law/rule. You’re depending on someone being honest about their situation, and I don’t trust very many people to tell the truth.

@Archer22 I’m interested in hearing your reasoning for going out of Oklahoma to hunt, because just about everyone I know is trying to find a place to hunt IN Oklahoma.
  • Like
Reactions: 4
I haven’t lost a deer in 19 years, but I wounded one three years ago that showed back up on camera alive. I quit hunting for the year after I wounded that one. I actually killed him the next season, and he was a lot bigger. I’m not opposed to having to “tag” a lost deer, but in my opinion, it’s an unenforceable law/rule. You’re depending on someone being honest about their situation, and I don’t trust very many people to tell the truth.

@Archer22 I’m interested in hearing your reasoning for going out of Oklahoma to hunt, because just about everyone I know is trying to find a place to hunt IN Oklahoma.
Dadgum Texican’s, I sure bet they are. That river isn’t deep enough or wide enough to keep y’all out!
You should be telling your buddies stay down there and protect that souther border we’ve got the whitetail situation handled.
  • Haha
  • Like
Reactions: 4
With all of the frigging poaching going on around here, I try to offset the "bagged but not tagged" a-holes in regards to our harvest numbers. We keep it up, and we'll start to wonder why our populations are in decline.
  • Like
Reactions: 4
It's the law in New Mexico that a wounded and lost animal is a punched tag.
I don't know if it's law in Oklahoma now , but back in the past, it was recommended while bird hunting if you shot a bird and didn't recover it, to add it to your daily limit, so I've pretty much followed that practice.
Only lost one deer, in my lifetime, finding the skeleton the following fall. I'd stopped about 50 yards too soon. There was no hair or blood at the place where he was hit with the MZ, with absolutely nothing after. The buck did the mule kick, and ran off like nothing happened. It was the last weekend of the MZ season if I remember right, but with the lack of blood, I would have continued to hunt, calling it a miss or grazing shot.
  • Like
Reactions: 2
Dadgum Texican’s, I sure bet they are. That river isn’t deep enough or wide enough to keep y’all out!
You should be telling your buddies stay down there and protect that souther border we’ve got the whitetail situation handled.
I can assure you that I try to discourage everyone I can. 🤷‍♂️
  • Haha
  • Like
Reactions: 4
Back in the 80's during archery season the wife hollered at me that there was a buck in the garden. I made a great shot. Waited a bit and went to tracking. Followed a good blood for a very long ways, well over and for a couple hours.

Deer crossed a stream and I lost to.

Two month slater during rifle season wife hollered there was buck in the garden. She took her 30 Herrett Contender and shot it the head.

When skinned it out i found the remains of my arrow in a healed up pocket in the tall vertebrae right over the shoulder. It appeared to month earlier I must have used my 30 yard pin to shoot at a 10 yard deer.

When we hunted in South Africa it was very clear a wounded animal was yours-trophy due and payable.
  • Like
Reactions: 3
@Archer22 I’m interested in hearing your reasoning for going out of Oklahoma to hunt, because just about everyone I know is trying to find a place to hunt IN Oklahoma.
lol. probably for that exact reason. As a general rule, I can't stand Texans so I'd love to get further away from them. lol jk.

I just like trying new states, different topography, different weather. Of course, the ecology is different, different animal and plant species. I mean, OK is pretty diverse, but hunting deer at Kaw Lake is just like hunting deer at Fort Gibson which is just like hunting deer at Arcadia Lake, etc. etc. Unless you're hunting the extreme east or west parts of OK, the entire middle section is pretty redundant. If it wasn't for the occasional deer hunt turning into a pig hunt, I think it'd get REALLY boring. I think that's also why I took up trad archery, I needed more of a challenge.

Besides, sitting on my usual public spot here in OK watching the goobers walk around in full orange with a crossbow in their hands gets really boring after a while. I do LOVE the feral dogs running under my treestand and adjacent property owners shooting their guns all hours of the day. I hope the other states I plan to hunt have those features too! ;)

On topic, I've wounded some deer in my archery career that I didn't recover, I never punched a tag. That said, sometimes I'd cool my jets on hunting for a while. I think there's too many variables to say "tag punched". As others have mentioned, deer can survive some serious stuff and I think it could be a bit unfair to waive a tag for a bad hit, that's part of hunting. You don't want it to happen, but sometimes it does.
See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 3
lol. probably for that exact reason. As a general rule, I can't stand Texans so I'd love to get further away from them. lol jk.
Yeah, I hate them sumbiching border jumpers too. :mad:
  • Haha
Reactions: 4
1 - 11 of 11 Posts
Top